Buying guide
How to pick a puppy from a litter
Choosing from a litter is exciting, and it’s easy to fall for the first puppy that runs over to you. But the right puppy is the one whose temperament fits your home, and the person who knows that best is usually the breeder, who has watched these puppies every day since they were born.
Start with the breeder
Many careful breeders match puppies to families rather than letting families pick first come, first served. That isn’t the breeder being controlling: they’ve seen which puppy is bold, which is gentle, which settles quickly and which never stops. Tell them honestly about your home, your schedule, any children or other pets, and what you want to do with your dog.
Some breeders also do a temperament evaluation at around seven weeks old. Ask whether they do, and what it showed.
Signs of a healthy puppy
- Clear, bright eyes and a clean nose, with no discharge.
- Clean ears without a strong smell.
- A clean coat and skin, with no bald patches, sores or fleas.
- Moves easily, without limping, and is a healthy weight for its age.
- Alert and interested when awake. Puppies sleep a lot, so visit more than once if you can.
Reading a puppy’s temperament
- How it reacts to you: comes over with curiosity, or hangs back. Neither is wrong, but notice it.
- How it handles being held: relaxes after a moment, or struggles the whole time.
- How it reacts to a new sound: startles and recovers quickly, or stays frightened.
- How it plays with littermates: confident, gentle, pushy or shy.
- Energy: the boldest puppy in the litter is often the most work. Pick the energy level that fits your life, not the one that’s most fun for ten minutes.
Questions to ask about the litter
- Which puppy do you think would suit us best, and why?
- How would you describe each puppy’s personality?
- What vet checks, vaccinations and deworming has each puppy had?
- What are the parents like, and how do their temperaments show up in this litter?
- Can I visit again before pickup?
Choose the breeder before the puppy
Picking the right puppy matters most once you’ve picked the right breeder: one who health tests both parents, raises puppies at home and has a written contract. See our questions to ask a dog breeder before you get to this step.
Health tests, breed by breed
Our breed guides list the health tests to ask for, the red flags and the questions to ask for each breed. And here is exactly what we check before a breeder can list on getabreeder.
Questions families ask
Should I pick the puppy that comes to me first?
Not necessarily. The first puppy to run over is often the boldest in the litter, which can mean the most energy and the most work. Choose the temperament that fits your home, and ask the breeder which puppy they’d suggest.
Should I let the breeder choose my puppy?
Many careful breeders match puppies to families, and that usually works out well because they know each puppy best. Be honest about your home and lifestyle, and ask them to explain their choice.
Is a male or female puppy better?
For most families, the individual puppy’s temperament matters more than its sex. Tell the breeder what you’re looking for and let them help you choose.